Order Taker or Risk Manager?
The Big Difference Between Insurance Agents
When most people think about insurance, they think about price.
“What’s the cheapest policy you’ve got?”
But the real difference between insurance agencies isn’t just price — it’s how they approach your risk.
Some agencies are simply order takers.
Others are risk managers and advisors.
The difference can mean thousands (or even millions) of dollars when a claim happens.
Let’s break it down.
The Order-Taking Agency
An order-taking agency does exactly what the name suggests:
You ask for a policy.
They provide a quote.
You buy it.
Their typical approach:
-
Focus on price first
-
Minimal questions about your situation
-
Little explanation of coverage gaps
-
Transaction-based relationship
-
Rarely review your policies unless you ask
This model isn’t always “bad,” but it is limited.
If you already know exactly what you need, it works.
But most people don’t fully understand their exposures — and that’s where problems start.
The risk:
You may be underinsured, missing endorsements, or carrying outdated limits.
And you often don’t find out until claim time.
The Risk Manager & Advisor Agency
A true advisor treats insurance like a financial safety net strategy, not a commodity.
They don’t start with price.
They start with your risks.
Their typical approach:
-
Ask detailed questions about your life or business
-
Identify exposures you may not see
-
Explain coverage options in plain English
-
Recommend appropriate limits and structures
-
Conduct regular policy reviews
-
Adjust coverage as your life or business changes
They operate more like a consultant than a salesperson.
A Simple Example
Order Taker:
“Here’s a $1M liability policy. Sign here.”
Advisor:
“You have a teenage driver, a pool, and a growing net worth. Let’s discuss umbrella coverage and asset protection.”
Same product category.
Very different outcome when something goes wrong.
Why This Matters More Than Ever
Lawsuits are larger.
Repair costs are higher.
Medical expenses keep rising.
Jury verdicts are unpredictable.
Cheap insurance that fails in a big claim is not a bargain — it’s a liability.
How to Tell Which Type You Have
Ask yourself:
-
Does my agent ask about changes in my life or business?
-
Did they explain why I need certain limits?
-
Do they proactively review my coverage?
-
Did they talk about risk, not just premiums?
-
Do I feel educated after meetings with them?
If the answer is “no” to most of these, you may have an order taker.
Final Thought
Insurance isn’t just about buying a policy.
It’s about protecting your future.
An order taker sells you a product.
A risk manager helps protect your lifestyle, your business, and your legacy.
And when a claim happens, that difference becomes crystal clear.