Why Integrity Matters When Choosing an Insurance Agent

Does Your Insurance Agent Have Integrity?  It Matters More Than You May Think.

When choosing an insurance agent, most people naturally focus on a few familiar things: price, coverage, company options, responsiveness, and service. Those are all important considerations. But there is another characteristic that deserves just as much attention, if not more: integrity.

Choosing an insurance agent

How does your agent conduct business when nobody is watching? Are they honest with insurance companies? Are they honest with their clients? Do they accurately represent the risks they insure, or are they willing to bend the truth to get a policy issued?

Unfortunately, there is a growing concern in the insurance industry that some agents are losing sight of what it means to conduct business ethically and honorably.

And consumers need to understand why that matters.

When Getting the Policy Becomes More Important Than Doing the Right Thing

Insurance agents have a responsibility to accurately represent their clients to insurance companies. That means providing complete and truthful information about the property, business operations, exposures, claims history, and other details that affect the insurance company’s decision to provide coverage.

Yet there are situations where agents deliberately misrepresent information to get a risk insured.

Sometimes the misrepresentation involves downplaying a business operation, omitting an exposure, changing how a property is used, or providing answers that the agent knows are not accurate. In other situations, the agent may tell the insurance company one thing while telling the client something entirely different.

Some agents even go so far as to mislead their own clients about what they are purchasing or what information is being provided to an insurance company.

Let’s be clear: this isn’t creative marketing or being aggressive on behalf of a client. It is dishonesty.

And while it might occasionally result in a policy being issued, it can create enormous problems when a claim occurs.

An insurance policy is a contract. The information used to obtain that contract matters. Material misrepresentations and omissions can create coverage disputes, jeopardize the policy, or potentially result in a claim being denied.

The agent who promised to get the job done may be nowhere to be found when the client needs that coverage the most.

What About Misleading the Client?

Perhaps even more troubling are situations where agents mislead the insured themselves.

One example involves Agent of Record (AOR) letters.

An Agent of Record letter is a legitimate document used to designate an insurance agent or agency as the representative of an insured for a particular insurance policy or account. There are perfectly appropriate reasons to use one.

….but there is a right way and a wrong way to obtain one.

An insured should understand exactly what they are signing, why they are signing it, and what authority they are giving another agent. Getting a client’s signature through misleading explanations, disguising the purpose of the document, or presenting it as something it isn’t is not acceptable business conduct.

A signature obtained through confusion or deception is not a demonstration of good salesmanship. It is a demonstration of a lack of integrity.

And if an agent is willing to deceive a prospective client just to obtain their business, what makes that client believe the agent will always be truthful when handling their insurance?

If They’re Willing to Lie to the Insurance Company, Why Would You Trust Them Not to Lie to You?

This is perhaps the most important point consumers should consider.

An insurance agent who is willing to lie to an insurance company on your behalf is not necessarily doing you a favor. In fact, they may be putting your financial security at risk.

Think about it. If an agent is comfortable misrepresenting your business operations, concealing information, or providing inaccurate answers to get a policy issued, what assurance do you have that they won’t misrepresent something to you when it serves their interests?

An agent who has no problem being dishonest with one party to accomplish their objective has already demonstrated that honesty is negotiable.

That is not the type of person most people would want advising them on their largest financial exposures.

Insurance is supposed to provide financial protection when something goes wrong. It is not supposed to be a transaction built on information that everyone hopes never gets examined.

The Right Way to Represent a Client

Being an advocate for an insured does not mean telling an insurance company whatever it wants to hear. It means understanding the client’s risks, identifying appropriate insurance markets, presenting those risks accurately, and working to find the best available solution.

Sometimes that means having difficult conversations.

Sometimes it means telling a client that a particular operation is difficult to insure. Sometimes it means explaining that an insurance company will not accept a certain exposure. And sometimes it means walking away from an opportunity because the terms, conditions, or underwriting requirements simply don’t make sense.

Those aren’t failures. They are part of being a professional.

A good insurance agent should be able to advocate aggressively for a client while remaining completely honest with the insurance companies they represent.

Those two things are not mutually exclusive.

In fact, they should go hand in hand.

A Few Questions Worth Asking Your Insurance Agent

Consumers don’t always know what happens behind the scenes when their insurance is being quoted or placed. But there are some very reasonable questions worth asking:

  1. Does my agent accurately represent my business, property, and exposures to the insurance company?
  2. Does my agent explain what information is being provided to the insurance company on my behalf?
  3. Does my agent take the time to explain documents before asking me to sign them?
  4. Will my agent tell me when a particular coverage or insurance company isn’t appropriate, even if it means losing the sale?
  5. Can I trust that the advice I’m receiving is based on my best interests rather than the agent’s desire to earn a commission?

These are not unreasonable expectations. They are basic standards that should be expected of anyone entrusted with protecting your financial well-being.

Integrity Still Matters

At the end of the day, insurance is a business built on promises, contracts, and trust. The insurance company promises to provide protection under the terms of the policy. The insured promises to provide accurate information and meet their contractual obligations. The insurance agent plays an important role in making sure both sides understand what they are agreeing to.

When an agent compromises that process through dishonesty, everyone can lose.

At Frost Insurance Agency, we believe that how business is conducted matters just as much as the business itself. We believe in representing our clients accurately, dealing honestly with insurance companies, explaining what our clients are signing, and providing advice that we can stand behind.

We don’t believe there is anything honorable about getting a policy issued through deception, and we don’t believe an insured should have to wonder whether their agent is telling them the truth.

The cheapest insurance policy isn’t necessarily the best policy. And the agent who promises to get you insured at any cost isn’t necessarily the agent you want protecting you.

When choosing an insurance professional, look beyond the price, the promises, and the sales pitch.

Look for integrity.

Because if you can’t trust your insurance agent to tell the truth, what exactly are you trusting them to protect?

To learn more about how proactive risk management and personalized advice can protect what matters most, contact Frost Insurance Agency. Call us at 419-446-2777, email frost@frostins.com, or click here to start a conversation about your risks and goals.  Prefer a face-to-face review? Visit one of our four convenient locations in Archbold, Napoleon, Holgate, or Whitehouse — and let’s build a protection plan, not just a policy.

REQUEST A QUOTE

    Search Blog

    Recent Articles